Mister Goodies Lynchburg, Va

Since 2005, Mister Goodies Ice Cream in Lynchburg, Va has served the community premium soft serve, homemade ice cream, vegan & dairy free ice cream, classic sundaes, shakes and more!

View fullsize The 2024 Mister Goodies Team! 😎 We had so much fun last night at our annual Staff Party, where we celebrated another successful season and shared fun memories from the past year! Mister Goodies has the absolute BEST employees in Lynchburg, some of t
View fullsize SEE YOU IN MARCH: we are officially CLOSED for the 2024 Season and the countdown has already started for our 2025 Season! We'll be BACK OPEN in March! THANK YOU for another amazing season! 2025 will be our 20th year. It's been a privilege to serve yo
View fullsize Happy Election Day! ❤️🤍💙 Try a RED, WHITE & BLUE GELATI, layered blue raspberry and cherry Italian ice and vanilla ice cream garnished with patriotic sprinkles and a mini American flag! 🇺🇲 We are OPEN 12-10 today #electionday #ElectionDay2024
View fullsize BROWNIE BATTER & MINT 💚 🍫 are the soft serve Flavors of the DAY! Try them twisted together for a MINT BROWNIE or get a brownie sundae made with the Mint Brownie ice cream. First time EVER we are running a line up of flavors for just one day, be
View fullsize ENCORE! 👏 Mister Goodies will be OPEN TODAY (11/4) from 12:00-10:00 and MAYBE tomorrow until supplies run out. You've kept us so busy and we're having so much fun serving you all! Because of your incredible support, we're keeping the party going an
View fullsize FINAL DAY OF THE 2024 SEASON! 🗓️ Today November 3rd is the LAST DAY before the long winter begins. This season went by FAST! Thanks again for an incredible year and we'll be BACK in MARCH 2025! Inventory is running low so we may be out of a few item
View fullsize CHRISTMAS GIFT CARD DEAL: buy $25 worth of gift cards, get $5 in gift cards FREE! The perfect stocking stuffer! 🎁 Available in any dollar increment with a minimum of $5 per card. Offer valid today and tomorrow only, 11/2-11/3! #buy25get5 #mistergood
View fullsize 3 DAYS LEFT BEFORE WE CLOSE ON NOVEMBER 3! ⌚ PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE NACHOS 🎃 🍰 are available through closing day! Our pumpkin soft serve drizzled in caramel with caramel dipping sauce, crispy waffle nachos and cheesecake pieces! We can also make tradit
View fullsize HALLOWEEN HOURS: Mister Goodies is OPEN limited hours today from 12:00-5:00 so that our staff can enjoy the Halloween festivities with friends and family! 🎃 Try one of our scary good limited time Halloween sundaes! 🐛 Dirt Worm Sundae (Oreos, fudge,
View fullsize DAIRY FREE/VEGAN PUMPKIN OREO is the newest homemade dairy free flavor at Mister Goodies! Made with GLUTEN FREE Oreos making this a GF option (all our dairy frees are GF). Mister Goodies has more Dairy Free options than any other ice cream shop in VA
View fullsize PUMPKIN & CHEESECAKE 🎃 🍰 are the new and FINAL round of Flavors of the Week for the 2024 Season! Swirl them together for a PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE twist or get the flavors separate. ROLL your cone in crushed graham crackers or get a Pumpkin Cheeseca
View fullsize Our BISCOFF COOKIE BUTTER SUNDAE has been a popular choice at Mister Goodies this season! 🍪 Our Cookie Butter soft serve drizzled in cookie butter sauce and crushed Biscoff pieces! 6 DAYS LEFT until we close for the season on Sunday November 3rd! #b

Hottest Spot in Lynchburg with the coolest treats around

Your one stop destination for all things ice cream. From premium soft serve ice cream to our homemade hard ice cream that we make on-site, Mister Goodies has something for everyone. Shaved ice, milkshakes, sundaes and specialty items like our cinnamon roll sundae or hot fudge brownie sundae are popular choices here. In 2017, Mister Goodies was one of the first ice cream shops in Virginia to notice the growing need for quality Vegan & Dairy Free options and started offering our expansive line of Vegan ice creams, made with almond milk. We are honored to serve thousands of customers every week, and with 3 serving windows and a state of the art ice cream trailer custom built by Hitch-Hiker Manufacturing, Mister Goodies service is the fastest and most efficient you’ll find anywhere (don’t let the long lines scare you away, it moves quick).

For 18 years and counting, Mister Goodies continues to lead the way for innovation and new ideas for ice cream and the dessert industry in the Lynchburg and Central Virginia area. Year after year, we are honored to win first place in the frozen dessert category in both the Lynchburg Living and News and Advance Best of Lynchburg awards. Check us out at 21556 Timberlake Rd next to CVS.

Strawberry Shortcake

Strawberry Shortcake

Hot Apple Dumpling

Hot Apple Dumpling

Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae

Ooey Gooey Peanut Butter Fudge Sundae

Dirt Worm Sundae

Dirt Worm Sundae

Funky Monkey Banana Split

Funky Monkey Banana Split

Traditional Banana Split

Traditional Banana Split

Freshly Baked Cookie Sandwich

Freshly Baked Cookie Sandwich

Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae

Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae

FAQs

  • We are a seasonal business open March through October.

  • No. We are an independently owned and operated business. Mister Goodies was started by Doug and Rhonda Ulrich in 2004. Mister Goodies is proud to be locally owned.

  • Yes! In fact, Mister Goodies is proud to offer more Dairy Free/Vegan options than any other ice cream shop in Virginia. We carry flavors of Dairy Free ice cream that we proudly make in house. In addition to that, we can make Dairy Free Storms, milkshakes, or sundaes. The possibilities are endless.

  • The short answer is: it depends. Our soft serve vanilla, chocolate, dreamsicle, and Flavorburst flavors are gluten and egg free. Other flavors like our Oreo hard serve contain gluten and our cookie dough ice cream contains egg. The best bet is to let us know when you’re ordering that you have a specific allergy so we can take extra precautions and alert you if a specific item contains an allergen.

  • Sunday through Thursday, 12:00-10:00. Friday & Saturday, 12:00-10:30

  • We make our own ice cream. Mister Goodies has an on-site commercial kitchen where we make all 16 of our hard serve ice cream flavors and our 8 Vegan/Dairy Free options. Our soft serve flavors are made in house as well. We believe “homemade is better”

  • We sell a low sugar soft serve called Only 8. It is “Only 8” calories per ounce and sweetened with a natural fruit based sugar. While it’s not 100% sugar free, it is low sugar.

  • We’re pretty much always busy. But here’s the thing: with 3 serving windows, the line moves fast and the average wait time is never more than 15-20 minutes (and that’s during our peak busy hour). After 20 years, Mister Goodies has perfected the art of serving our customers quickly and efficiently. Don’t let the line scare you away, it moves fast!

Want to join the Mister Goodies team?

The best (and sweetest) job in Lynchburg! Great pay, tips and work culture. We care about you and want to see you succeed. Applicants must be at least 16. Apply below or stop by Mister Goodies for an application!